Remodel vs Renovation: Key Differences Explained

Knowing the difference between renovation and remodeling is important when planning a masonry project. Renovation updates and refreshes existing spaces without changing the structure, like painting or refinishing floors. It's cost-effective and less disruptive. Remodeling involves major changes like altering layouts or adding new rooms, offering a complete transformation and potentially increasing value.

At APS Masonry Contracting in Philadelphia, our expert team can help you choose the best option for your goals and budget. 

What Is The Difference Between A Remodel And A Renovation?

The key difference between remodel and renovation lies in the extent of changes made to a space. Renovation primarily involves updating an existing area to give it a fresh, rejuvenated feel. This often includes refinishing surfaces or replacing fixtures. Conversely, remodeling entails more substantial modifications, such as altering layouts or adding entirely new rooms. Tasks like knocking down walls or incorporating extra bathrooms fall squarely into the remodeling category. So, whether you're sprucing up with finishes or embarking on a structural transformation, understanding this distinction is key for your home improvement project.

Reach Out for a Free Estimate

What is remodeling?

Remodeling goes beyond simple updates; it means altering the structure of a space, essentially giving it a complete "remake" rather than a mere "revival" of the existing state. When a project transforms a room's layout, structure, and style, that's remodeling. You're not just updating or tweaking; you're making definitive changes to the look and layout. If your project involves a significant change that gives the space a new look and feel, it's safe to say you're remodeling, not just renovating. See our blog on remodel tips for more information.

What are some examples of remodeling projects?

Depending upon the structure, shape, size, and manufacturing processes, CMUs are mainly classified into two types:

Remodeling offers a world of possibilities, and there are numerous examples of how it can better transform your living spaces to suit your needs and style. Some common remodeling projects include:

• Creating Open-Concept Spaces: Combining your kitchen and living room creates an open-concept layout that enhances flow and connectivity.
• Functional Kitchen Islands: Installing a kitchen island for more efficient cooking and additional storage.
• Optimizing Floor Plans: Changing floor plans to align with your lifestyle and preferences better.
• Enhancing Climate Control: Adding central AC for improved comfort and climate control throughout your home.
• Expanding with Additions: Building additions like a sunroom or home office to increase your living space and functionality.
• Utilizing Basements: Finishing a basement to create extra living space for entertainment or guest rooms.
• Vertical Expansion: Adding a second level to your home for more space without expanding your home's footprint.
• Outdoor Living Spaces: Building a deck or patio to create an inviting outdoor living area for relaxation and entertainment.
• Luxurious Bedroom Suites: Adding a bedroom suite for a more private and luxurious living space.
• Cozy Fireplace: Incorporating a brick fireplace and chimney adds warmth, character, and ambiance to your home.

What are the pros and cons of remodeling?

Undertaking a remodeling project to update your current masonry structure can be a significant decision, and like any important choice, it comes with its share of benefits and drawbacks. It's essential to carefully weigh these factors to make an informed decision that aligns with your goals, budget, and lifestyle.

Remodeling in masonry offers a range of enticing benefits:

• Customization: You can tailor your home's layout to suit your needs and preferences better. Whether reconfiguring interior spaces or creating a specific design aesthetic, remodeling allows you to make your living environment uniquely yours.
• Increased Square Footage: Remodeling can add valuable square footage to your home, such as an extra bedroom or bathroom. This expansion accommodates your current requirements and provides flexibility for future needs, like a growing family or a home office.
• Enhanced Functionality: Modern amenities and conveniences can seamlessly integrate into your masonry structure during a remodel. This includes upgraded plumbing, electrical systems, and climate control, enhancing your home's overall functionality and comfort.
• Property Value Boost: A well-executed stone masonry remodel can significantly increase the value of your property. Potential buyers often pay a premium for updated and modern masonry buildings, making them more appealing in the real estate market. This investment can provide substantial returns in the long run.

While remodeling in masonry can offer numerous benefits, there are some potential drawbacks to consider:

• Higher Costs: A remodeling project is more expensive than renovations, especially if you opt for high-end masonry materials or hire professional contractors. The structural changes and extensive modifications involved can drive up costs significantly.
• Budget Escalation: Expenses in remodeling projects can quickly escalate, requiring meticulous planning and budgeting to avoid financial surprises. Unexpected issues or structural changes may lead to additional costs, making it essential to have a contingency fund and a well-defined project plan to stay on track financially.

What is renovation?

Renovation in masonry projects involves updating a space or room while retaining its original layout and structure. Common renovation tasks include painting, replacing flooring, and updating light fixtures, often manageable as DIY projects.

Typically, renovations only require permits if local building codes mandate them. 

The essence of renovating is to refresh or revive a building without altering its original design. Custom renovations add a personalized touch, tailoring a room to your lifestyle. Even smaller updates like a fresh coat of paint or window replacements can yield a satisfying return on investment, enhancing aesthetics and functionality.

Reach Out for a Free Estimate

What are some examples of renovation projects?

A renovation project in masonry can vary widely depending on the specific goals and needs of the project. Here are some examples of renovation tasks commonly undertaken:

• Refinishing Floors: This involves restoring the original luster of masonry floors or changing their color to give the building a fresh look.
• Painting Walls or Ceilings: A fresh coat of paint can work wonders in reinvigorating a room's appearance, whether it's to update the color scheme or refresh the existing one.
• Cabinet Refacing: In kitchens and bathrooms, cabinet refacing can give a modern and updated appearance without needing full replacements.
• Light Fixture Swapping: Upgrading or changing light fixtures can improve lighting quality and align with a new aesthetic or design theme.
• Plumbing Fixture Updates: Replacing faucets or showerheads enhances functionality and adds a touch of style to kitchens and bathrooms.
• Door Hardware Change: Updating knobs or handles on doors can improve security and bring a fresh look to interior and exterior doors.
• Trim or Molding Addition: Adding trim or molding can create visual interest and architectural depth, elevating the overall aesthetics of the construction. It can be used to define spaces or highlight architectural features.

What are the pros and cons of renovations?

Renovating a masonry project offers numerous advantages, making it an attractive option for homeowners. Here are some key pros of renovations:

• Cost-Effective Updates: Renovations are typically more budget-friendly than full-scale remodeling, making them accessible to more homeowners.
• Property Value Boost: Major renovations, such as kitchen or bathroom upgrades, can substantially increase the resale value of your home.
• Enhanced Market Appeal: Renovated homes often attract more potential buyers and may sell faster due to their updated and refreshed appearance.

There's another side to consider when it comes to renovating. Here are some potential drawbacks to masonry renovations:

• Budgetary Considerations: Although renovations are generally more cost-effective than remodeling, costs can accumulate, necessitating thorough budgeting and project prioritization to avoid financial strain.
• Disruptions to Daily Life: Renovation projects can disrupt your daily routine due to noise, dust, and the presence of contractors. This can be particularly challenging for families with young children or remote workers who require a quiet environment.
• DIY Risks: Attempting DIY renovations can lead to issues, potentially resulting in additional costs or unsatisfactory results. Assessing your skills and capabilities to a realistic degree is important before tackling renovation projects independently.

Get A Quote

Remodeling Vs Renovating, Which Costs More?

The question of remodel vs renovation is complicated, but price-wise, renovations generally tend to cost less upfront and are easier to budget, focusing on updating existing features like plumbing fixtures or cabinets. On the other hand, while typically more expensive, remodeling allows for more significant changes that enhance a home's value and functionality. Complex remodeling projects often demand professional expertise, ensuring the job is done correctly and potentially increasing the home's worth. Although remodeling can involve hidden costs like rerouting electrical or plumbing systems, these steps are essential for realizing desired layouts or adding new functionalities. Both remodeling and renovating involve new finishes and fixtures, but remodeling offers a broader transformation aligned with lifestyle and needs.

Should I Renovate Or Remodel?

Choosing between renovation and remodeling for your masonry project can be challenging. However, there are various approaches and considerations to help you narrow down the right choice that aligns with your goals, budget, and lifestyle. When deciding between renovating and remodeling your home, consider asking yourself the following questions:

What's the budget for your project?

How many years do you see yourself living in this home?

What's the end game for this home improvement?

Do you have the DIY know-how and time to tackle this yourself?

Is increasing your home's value a priority?

How will this work disrupt your day-to-day activities?

Are you planning to bring in a professional contractor?

Is selling the property in the near future part of your plans?

What Adds The Most Value To A Renovation?

According to Remodeling's 2023 Cost vs. Value Report, the following masonry-related home renovation pros typically add the most value to a property:

1. Garage door replacement.
2. Manufactured stone veneer.
3. Entry door replacement.
4. Siding.
5. Minor kitchen remodel.
6. Window replacement.
7. Deck addition.

These projects are known to provide a favorable return on investment, making them attractive options for homeowners looking to increase their property's value.

Should I Remodel Or Tear Down And Rebuild?

When faced with the decision between remodeling an existing home or opting for a complete rebuild, numerous complex factors come into play. APS Masonry Contracting possesses valuable experience in both restoration and rebuilding, each presenting its unique advantages and challenges. The choice of remodel or rebuild often hinges on various elements, such as neighborhood dynamics and property values. In areas with stable or rising property values, tearing down and rebuilding may be preferred, especially if the existing home doesn't align with the community's character.

Conversely, restoration may be the wiser choice in declining areas or when preserving historical or architectural value is of utmost importance. Local building codes, structural conditions, existing features, and financial considerations are key in decision-making. Evaluating potential resale values and consulting professionals for cost-benefit analyses is vital. APS Masonry Contracting is ready to guide you through these numerous considerations, ensuring an informed decision for your unique circumstances.

Call us today